It's a mark of intellectual infantilism to rely too much on lazy System 1's heuristic, superficial jump to conclusion brain. I've seen this in how cognitive decline's demolition of System 2's harder working analytical brain in my parents and mother in law brought them into a second childhood governed entirely by primary emotions.
It's a mark of intellectual and emotional maturity to prefer System 2's analytical brain and be suspicious of easy, lazy leaps of faith, both metaphorical and literal. Living outside the consensus is lonely and demands more emotional work since the universe is utterly indifferent to what comforts us. Seneca knew this. So did Kahneman. You gotta love a psychologist who stole the Nobel Prize in economics from the economists.